Why does makeup always look so bad on me?

I'm new to makeup and I can't help but feel relieved every time I wash my face and take off the makeup because at this point literally even my bare face looks better.

I'm not sure why.

- I wear concealer on dark spots of my face as well as high planes (cheekbones, nose)

- I do a black (not too thick) winged eyeliner and i also do this eyeliner on the outer 1/3 of my lower lash line

- I wear mascara, under eye pink blush, lip-liner and a pink lip

My features: I have sort of a fuller face, large round eyes, a medium sized nose, small but full lips and I'm light-medium olive skinned with brown curly hair. In case that helps with harmonizing or anything